X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bcroe
    Solar Fanatic
    • Jan 2012
    • 5198

    The first snow of the season arrived in NW ILL, half a foot of heavy wet stuff. Perfect for a snowman, not so good for solar
    panels. This will test the latest snow handling experiment here.

    The South facing array design isn't ideal at this time, with limited spacing between portrait mounted panel rows. And the slope
    is still in summer mode, not easy to change on this design. BUT it does have gaps between rows of panels. With temps above
    freezing some of the heavy snow was already trying to slide off. Note that the snow on upper panels didn't slide onto
    the lower panels; it started falling through the 6" gap. With the snow depth equal to the gap size, it needed a little
    encouragement to finish the trip. That is OK, the next version will have an 8" gap. One platform had a 4" gap, which did
    not work well in this situation.

    I got out the snow pusher and started clearing panels. Both upper and lower panels were partly clear, not a huge job. No
    more pushing 10 feet of snow over 10 feet of panels. Just pull the remaining snow to the bottom of each panel and off.
    When finished the snow pile in front of the array is much smaller than when all the snow landed there. Eventually I'll need
    to blow it farther away, but not this time. Bruce Roe PV16D2.JPG
    PV16D3.JPG
    PV16D1.JPG
    Last edited by bcroe; 12-06-2016, 04:25 PM.

    Comment

    • DanKegel
      Banned
      • Sep 2014
      • 2093

      Really enjoying following your solar adventures, thanks.

      Comment

      • SunEagle
        Super Moderator
        • Oct 2012
        • 15125

        Originally posted by DanKegel
        Really enjoying following your solar adventures, thanks.
        Just be honest and say you miss the nice white stuff.

        Comment

        • littleharbor
          Solar Fanatic
          • Jan 2016
          • 1998

          If those are vertically oriented panels in your last pic, on the left, what kind of production are you getting on sunny days? It looks like you would get quite a bit of reflection off the snow.
          2.2kw Suntech mono, Classic 200, NEW Trace SW4024

          Comment

          • bcroe
            Solar Fanatic
            • Jan 2012
            • 5198

            Originally posted by littleharbor
            If those are vertically oriented panels in your last pic, on the left, what kind of production are you getting on sunny days? It looks like you would get quite a bit of reflection off the snow.
            Of course those panels are near vertical and facing the eastern rising sun. Mounted on the other side are mirror image panels
            facing the setting sun. Reflection of the sun off the snow does help. When the array is reconstructed (using the same panels),
            the tilt will be much simpler to change seasonably. The panels will be landscape mounted with 8" gaps. The orientation
            arrangement is still under consideration.

            Severe overcast that day severely limited production, but the dispersed light pretty much put all panels of any orientation to work.
            5 to 20% was about it, but it would be half that without the extra panels. At least the plant still had something to do, it all adds up.

            Next time might be a little lighter snow, below melting temps. In the past 90 minutes were needed to clear the panels; need to
            measure any time savings. This time certainly reduced the muscle required, and the amount of snow blowing of piled up snow.
            Bruce Roe

            Comment

            • DanKegel
              Banned
              • Sep 2014
              • 2093

              Originally posted by SunEagle
              Just be honest and say you miss the nice white stuff.
              no lie! taking train to minneapolis for xmas, will get my fill then.

              Comment

              • DanS26
                Solar Fanatic
                • Dec 2011
                • 972

                Bruce, liked your snow pics. Has not reached southern Indiana yet, but our day will come.

                Quick question.....your PVOutput.org site "SUN HOURS" indicates a 60 panel array at 15,000 watts.....from the pics your arrays are much larger? I count 72 south facing panels and 40 east/west panels. I'm confused since it really messes with your efficiency ratings.

                Comment

                • bcroe
                  Solar Fanatic
                  • Jan 2012
                  • 5198

                  Originally posted by DanS26
                  Bruce, liked your snow pics. Has not reached southern Indiana yet, but our day will come.

                  Quick question.....your PVOutput.org site "SUN HOURS" indicates a 60 panel array at 15,000 watts.....from the pics your arrays are much larger? I count 72 south facing panels and 40 east/west panels. I'm confused since it really messes with your efficiency ratings.
                  DANS26, Yes it DOES mess with my efficiency ratings. Your counting is pretty good, it may change again, and the panels
                  aren't all the same size. The rest of the plant is fixed at 15KW, the peak I can get to the meter is 14.7.

                  Those numbers are the original design before it changed. Since its now quite different from a "classic SW desert" design,
                  dealing with NW IL conditions, with panels that can never all receive direct sun at the same time, just what is it? I would
                  say panels are the cheapest part of the system and its very good at maximizing the plant use for this area; some would say
                  its a terribly inefficient use of PV panels. The numbers listed let the efficiency be calculated in a way more consistent with
                  the design intent and conditions here; the KWH are accurate.

                  I didn't know anyone actually looked at my PVOutput. Sometimes I see a system around my latitude with more inverter
                  but less panels than me and wonder how they compare. If its cloudy or the sun is poor at mid day I will collect more energy;
                  if its sunny all day I will collect less than the other system. Bruce Roe

                  Comment

                  • DanS26
                    Solar Fanatic
                    • Dec 2011
                    • 972

                    I look for systems around the Midwest that are 15kW or greater and do some long time frame comparisons with my system. My system is Steamboat Landing Solar #128 of 25,503.

                    A couple of years ago a moderator here, I believe his name was "russ" contended that most people do not report correctly on PVOutput, mainly over report. I disagreed and so I'm always on the lookout for systems that do not conform to the norm or their stats and ratios are abnormal.

                    Comment

                    • bcroe
                      Solar Fanatic
                      • Jan 2012
                      • 5198

                      Originally posted by DanS26
                      I look for systems around the Midwest that are 15kW or greater and do some long time frame comparisons with my system. My system is Steamboat Landing Solar #128 of 25,503.

                      A couple of years ago a moderator here, I believe his name was "russ" contended that most people do not report correctly on PVOutput, mainly over report. I disagreed and so I'm always on the lookout for systems that do not conform to the norm or their stats and ratios are abnormal.
                      Sometimes in the summer inverters here are essentially pegged for 10 hours (9.8 sun hours best) and I do a comparisons. There
                      were a few listings with impossible numbers (can the sun shine 200 hours a day?). Don't know if they are still there. Bruce Roe

                      Comment

                      • DanS26
                        Solar Fanatic
                        • Dec 2011
                        • 972

                        i thought PVOutput had input limits. How do you get around that on those high production days?

                        Comment

                        • bcroe
                          Solar Fanatic
                          • Jan 2012
                          • 5198

                          Originally posted by DanS26
                          i thought PVOutput had input limits. How do you get around that on those high production days?
                          I don't do anything. A quick look under efficiency shows a 0.050 KW system generating 5.387KWH (108 sun hours), so I guess they
                          don't have limits. Next one down is about 20 sun hours, then they get back to reality. In theory a tracker could about match me. Bruce

                          Comment

                          • bcroe
                            Solar Fanatic
                            • Jan 2012
                            • 5198

                            Holiday PV Report

                            Winter is really here in NW IL, the high today was 0 deg F. We have had several snow storms, the last 2 extended some 36
                            hours. The first morning it was very overcast, with not enough power to even light off the PV inverters. With more snow
                            coming I'm not cleaning the PV panels yet. I'm thinking this will be the first time in 40 months that output is 0 KWH. But then
                            the the sun brightened, the inverters started, and I made 3 KWH. The perfect record of SOME energy collected every day is
                            maintained. Same thing on the storm ending this morning, Saturday made 7 KWH.

                            This morning maybe 5" of very cold, light snow covered the south facing panels. One tap and it fell off the E-W panels. I went
                            after the S panels with a double acting steam engine stroke, push the snow off the top going up, pull it off the bottom going down.
                            The cold snow wasn't sticky, it just dropped through the 6" panel gap easily. 72 panels cleared in 25 minutes is certainly a speed
                            record here, and some of the time only using one hand. Past winters without snow gaps have taken 90 minutes.

                            With 3 days of decent sun coming up, the panels are delivering. I didn't check the voltage rise, but the sun cleared all trees by
                            noon and PV ran at the peak capability of 15KW. Even with 2 large and a couple smaller resistance heaters running in the
                            house, more power is generated than consumed (while the sun is high). Just look at that meter reverse arrow blinking!

                            Below zero, there are several big rooms I just leave the inefficient incandescent lights turned on in continuously, and they do
                            an EFFICIENT job of helping keep the inside in the 71 to 73 degree range.

                            Monday promises to be quite sunny, so as about the shortest day of the year, I should make one last power curve measurement
                            on the test panels. Then there will be a complete half year set of curves to contemplate for the rest of winter. Perhaps, leading to
                            some drastic changes. There are 3 more trees back there not likely to survive 2017. 2 years ago they were trimmed, but they
                            just grew right back. No coming back this time, and I can't claim these trees were in the fence line. I'm getting more
                            dispassionate about this. Bruce Roe

                            Comment

                            • bcroe
                              Solar Fanatic
                              • Jan 2012
                              • 5198

                              Another test today, at least an inch of pretty wet snow followed by temps slightly above freezing. 96% of the snow had already slid
                              off the poorly (summer) elevated South facing panels. It seemed pretty clear to me, if snow from the upper panels had had to slide down
                              the lower panels to clear, there would have been FAR more snow for me to clear. But it fell through the snow gaps.

                              It was pretty overcast, but panels still work best with no sunlight obstructions. I spent like 7 minutes to get everything 100% clear. A
                              peek at the inverters revealed 5.5KW output, pretty good considering the sun was invisible; well worth the effort. Bruce Roe

                              Comment

                              • dennis461
                                Junior Member
                                • Nov 2015
                                • 58

                                Why re-invent the wheel.
                                The data you are looking for, using your method, will be dependant on your type of lanels.
                                The feds uses power per square meter, http://www.nrel.gov/gis/solar.html, kwm/m2/day.

                                How much actual power is then less than calculated for your area based on your equipment/installation.


                                PVWatts should tell you all you need to know, right?




                                Dennis
                                SE5000 18 each SW185

                                Comment

                                Working...