Earth4Energy, Citizenre, and other Misleading Solar Energy Scam Info

[Mike90250]

Hi Jason

Although this may read like this, I really am not wishing to raise a red flag to a bull, but I am surprised by your sweeping statements about not buying Earth4Energy and similar products.

I have bought 5 of these guides (5 different guides!) and acquired others from the Internet. I have read all the manuals / guides and watched more than a dozen hours of video.

I fully agree that their claims that you can stop paying for your electricity are ludicrous.

But their claims that you can make your own solar panel for around $150 are valid. Sure, you are assembling solar cells to construct a solar panel, but if I am putting in a new bathroom I don't expect to "make" my own loo - I buy one and install it. .....

I'm making my own loo, http://humanurehandbook.com/ but I'll expect to buy PV panels. The scam part of the "plans" is that they lead you on to think by building one $150 panel, from scrap parts in your backyard, you can be done with the electric. You can't. They know it, but they still sell that way.

[Jason]

Hi Phil, thanks for your thoughts. I changed around some wording and added some helpful links...i suppose "scam" is a strong word.

Out of curiosity, after spending over $200 on these 5 manuals you have purchased, have you managed to build a decent $150 panel? If not, be sure to share your experience as you go along and ask any questions you may have.

[philpaine]

Throwing Out the Baby with the Bath Water

Hi Jason

Although this may read like this, I really am not wishing to raise a red flag to a bull, but I am surprised by your sweeping statements about not buying Earth4Energy and similar products.

I have bought 5 of these guides (5 different guides!) and acquired others from the Internet. I have read all the manuals / guides and watched more than a dozen hours of video.

I fully agree that their claims that you can stop paying for your electricity are ludicrous.

But their claims that you can make your own solar panel for under $200 are valid. Sure, you are assembling solar cells to construct a solar panel, but if I am putting in a new bathroom I don't expect to "make" my own loo - I buy one and install it.

These guides do show you how to make a solar panel and some of them do a very good job of it. While I agree the best manuals could be better, the best instructional videos are excellent and do show you, step by step, what to do. In terms of a product that claims to show you how to make your own solar panels, the best of these products does deliver. Therefore, in my book they are not scams.

Furthermore, in addition to going through the construction process in detail, some of these products include some excellent videos on the wider aspects of solar energy and electricity. One guide in particular stands out for providing more than 3 hours of video presentations on the fundamentals of electricity, how to use solar energy, etc. I have not found this material anywhere else on the web - it is very good indeed.

I'll quit the rambling now.

Yes, any claims that making a single solar panel is going to make a substantial difference to your electricity bill is bunkum.

To imply that you have all the materials available in your backyard is bunkum (you might have some wood and even some plexiglass, but I doubt that you have 36 solar cells sitting on the shelf!)

But to state that the guides will show you how to construct your own solar panel for under $200 is valid and should be acknowledged.

If you want to make solar panels, the best of these guides and instructional videos, do exactly that. That is not a scam.

So lets not throw out the baby with the bath water. By all means point out any errors/misleading statements in the advertising, but there is an awful lot of good material in some of these products that I have not been able to find elsewhere, it is such a shame that they feel the need to make/imply misleading claims.

Kind regards

Phil

[Phillip Rehman]

Hey guys, I really am thankfull that I joined this site. I almost bought a book set from solar4home. But decided to look deeper when there was no contact phone number. Reading your posts just saved me a crap load of heart-ache!!!! Thanks, Phillip

[jojo25]

thanks for having this forum...these con artists are so hard core that I had to sift through to the 9th page on Google before I found this site...searching for scams on greendiyenergy...they've posted page after page of bogus "reviews" and site telling me it really isn't a scam...the lady doth protest too much

thanks again

Yes, I agree Bob

Preferably someone in a timezone opposite of mine perhaps

Someone with a LOT of VB moderating experience, a gentle but firm hand, and good a sense of humor too.

[MarineLiner]

Replies always concern to the thread topic

That's great.
And preferably who also can keep that replies always concern to the thread topic.
Who also can guide and respons to "bad" information. I appreciate one of our Mike did it.
btw: i'm waiting for why i got caught. Thank you very much.

[Jason]

Yes, I agree Bob

Preferably someone in a timezone opposite of mine perhaps

i'm on this site all day, but as soon as I go to sleep the spammers come out

You need another mod mate.

[MarineLiner]

Got caught up in the spam queue

From: Solar Panel Forum
Date: Tue, 30 Jun 2009 12:38:26 -0500
Subject: Reply to thread 'First Solar Producing Jasun has just replied to a thread you have subscribed to entitled - First Solar Producing Panels For $.98 A Watt - in the General Discussion forum of Solar Panel Forum.
This thread is located at:

http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?t=677&goto=newpost

Here is the message that has just been posted:
***************
sorry marineliner...your post got caught up in the spam queue and I didn't notice it until now
***************

[MarineLiner]

Difference time of where we live

Could be caused by the difference of time where we live.
But i'm not sure, or just coincidence?
We are happy if more come to share knowledge and experience.
Hope people will perform ethically in looking for money.

[MarineLiner]

Yes, it could discourage some folks

Yes, it could discourage some folks, that's true. .....
It is good that there's a demand out there, that these marketers recognise this demand and are chasing this demand. This demand is what is pushing us forward towards a clean renewable future.

Yes, it could discourage some folks, that's true. It didn't discourage me, as the ebook I got just made it clear to me that the DIY path was not for me, but it did say to use ebay for most purchases, so I then started buying completed panels and stuff off ebay. The first time I put a solar panel, regulator, inverter and a battery together, and got power, now that was some magic.

It is good that there's a demand out there, that these marketers recognise this demand and are chasing this demand. This demand is what is pushing us forward towards a clean renewable future.

[Jason]

In some ways it's good to see that there's so much demand out there in the market for renewable energies. If folks do spend $47.00 on these various ebooks, they'll soon realise it's not as easy and as cheap as they claim in the sales copy. This is something that can put them on the right path as they digest some of the information purchased in these ebooks. I don't think they're a total waste. A lot of good can come from them.

I understand your POV in the following situation: Your average person (not intending on getting PV at the time) runs across the ad, gets caught in the sales trap, buys it, then starts to question. This leads to them (hopefully) seeking more information about PV. It's just unfortunate this is the way they had to be introduced to it. But I'm thinking a bigger percentage of people would read through it, realize it's not as easy as the sales pitch made it out to be, get pissed they wasted the money, end of story.

If someone is on this forum, they are already somewhat interested and seeking more information about PV. This post warns them of these ebooks and they save the $49.97. Also, I'm hoping this thread can get some search engine love to inform those who do a little research on the product before they purchase it.

[MarineLiner]

Most of that info is available freely

...., but most of that info is available freely on the net anyways, for anyone willing to do some hunting about. Google is your friend. Also searching on youtube can be helpful too. Lots of DIY solar and wind project vids on youtube.

...., they'll soon realise it's not as easy and as cheap as they claim in the sales copy.