Try our solar cost and savings calculator
Sailboat Power
Collapse
X
-
Exactly what I was going to say. I'll let Chris continueLast edited by Mike90250; 03-26-2014, 01:54 AM.Leave a comment:
-
Say, Dennis,
One thing I do not see in your DC loads is your windlass. I guarantee you that you are not going to armstrong a Danforth or Buegel and 50 feet of Grade 100 rode into the anchor well on a 50 foot yacht. The windlass draws a LOT of power. Usually enough so that some installations have a separate battery by the windlass to help minimize voltage drop in the wiring.Leave a comment:
-
I really see no problem with any of the DC loads. That is all normal stuff on a liveaboard cruising yacht. I mean, you are not going to go thru the boat at night and turn on every freaking light you can find. At least experienced sailors don't. You switch to your red night lighting after dark because if you are a husband/wife crew one of you is on watch 24 hours a day at sea. If whoever is on watch goes on deck to trim sails or something at 2:00 AM you can't go on deck blind from your pupils not being adjusted to the poorly lit conditions on deck in rough seas. It is a good way to end up dead.
The problem is the AC stuff. It all has to go. That is only doable on shore power or onboard marine generator at sea. And even then it cannot be done with a 12V system. Doing a complete refit on the boat for 24 or 32/36V and fitting a marine generator would make it possible. But a marine generator also requires fitting additional tankage for diesel. I don't recall what the diesel tankage is for a Columbia 50, but our H-R 54 carried 238 gallons of diesel, and that is primarily for the generator and not the propulsion engine. Boats without a generator are usually lucky to carry 75 gallons of diesel tankage.
Compounding the problem with the Columbia 50 is that they are a relatively slow boat with a short LWL, heavily ballasted and small sail area/displacement ratio. On a passage where we can make 200-220 nm in a day, a slower boat is going to make about 150-160. So 10 days at sea for us ends up being 14-15 days at sea for a slower boat. That means you have to carry 150% more supplies and tankage than a faster boat would on the same passage.
I really suggest getting on as crew on a boat making a passage. Or hiring an experienced captain to take you out on your boat for a passage to get an idea of what you have to look forward to. I'm detecting the "dream" that a lot of folks have here, but maybe not quite enough time spent at sea to realize the limitations of living onboard a sailing yacht several days out to sea. You are not going to have all the comforts and conveniences you have at home. And the first time you sail in a storm for two days in 20-30 foot seas you are going to wish you were enjoying the comforts of home instead of being up for 48 hours straight on a sailboat to keep it from becoming a statistic lost at sea.
On the other hand, if you plan on living in a slip most of the time and island hopping in the eastern Caribbean where you are never more than a day from the next island - then you can get away with more stuff. All depends on what your goals are.Leave a comment:
-
Dennis seriously what you want is not possible no mattery how much money you throw at it. You will need another boat to hold everything. .Leave a comment:
-
I mean, getting rid of the George Foreman grille and replacing it with a Magma Marine grille for instance. We do ALL our cooking on the Magma grille and it doesn't consume a single electron.
Things like the NorCold 'fridge...........well...........that's debatable. We just have a good old fashioned ice box in our boat that again doesn't consume any power. And it keeps meat and fish that we catch while cruising just fine for a 10 day passage.
I don't know if you are a crew of two, or if you are single-handing your boat. But things like how many hours a day the watermaker has to run depends on how many souls there are onboard.
If you are an experienced sailor there is folks in just every port looking for crew that will work for room and board to get to a different location on the planet. IF you have never done any cruising I would suggest finding somebody looking for crew, and crewing on a boat on a passage to get a better understanding of what is possible to do and what isn't. Your list of just the AC loads are totally undoable without an onboard genset and a 24V system.
And you did not include the important things like nav gear, radar, VHF, etc. that are essential for safe and legal operation of a sailing yacht on the high seas. Those are primary. The rest is secondary.Leave a comment:
-
This was going to be at the top of the previous posts ...
Bogart Engineering Pentametric Battery Monitor-Look at all the toys on that website ... Thanks for the reference as I really needed some good monitoring tools. These look perfect !!
TWO banks of batteries ?? So if I buy 8 batteries, I'll have two banks of 4 batteries each ?? Is that right?
The West Marine MasterVolt batteries come highly rated if you scour the web. I don't get why hooking a pair of 6 volt batteries in series, then hooking up pairs of these in parallel is any better than simply hooking up 12 volt batteries in parallel ??? I've seen that multiples of smaller batteries don't have the staying power that the larger batteries have in real work application - regardless of what the number say. Sorry, just don't get this one. From what I read online, the MasterVolt was a better battery in performance tests than the Concorde, though it is a reputable manufacturer.Leave a comment:
-
Daily D/C Equipment Amp Hour Requirements:
Groco Head Flushing (Can Manually Pump):
18 Amps x 15 minutes/Day = .25 Amp Hours --> Call it 5 Amp Hours/Day
Katadyn Watermaker 80E (3.5GPH) = 8 Amps x (4 hours = 14 Gallons) = 32 Amp Hours/Day
Bilge Pumps (Shower & under the motor)
Primary Bilge Pump (Figure 10 Seconds/15 Minutes = 40 Seconds/Hour = 16 Minutes/Day --> 0.25 Hours/Day)
11 Amps x 0.25 Hours/Day --> Call it 3 Amp Hours/Day
Shower Bilge = 4 Amps x (0.5 hours – 1 hour)/Day --> 4 Amp Hours (Max)/Day
Weems & Plath Chart Light: (Figure 10 Minutes/Hour x 12 Hours = 120 Minutes/Day, i.e. 2 Hours)
0.33 Amps x 2 Hours/Day = 0.66 Amp Hours --> Call it 1 Amp Hour/Day
Refrigerator: 3.1 Amps x 24 hours/Day --> Call it 75 Amp Hours/Day
Water Pump: (14 Amps or 20 Amps??) x 3 Hours/Day? = 60 Amp Hours/Day
Endless Breeze Fan: 2.58 Amps (On High) x 12 Hours (10-14 Hrs/Day) = 30.96 (Max=36.12) Amp Hours/Day
Note: Will be using several of these on low
Interior Lights:
Foreword Sink CCF Single Light: 0.63 Amps x 0.5 Hours/Day = 0.3 Amp Hours/Day
Shower Lights (Would use one or the other below so figure 1 Amp Hour / Day)
Shower Light: 0.92 Amps x (0.5 hours – 1 Hour)/Day = 0.92 (Max) Amp Hours/Day
Shower Shelf Light: 0.9 Amps x (0.5 hours – 1 Hour)/Day = 0.9 (Max) Amp Hours/Day
Fore Brass Swivel Light: 1.66 Amps x 6 Hours/Day = 9.96 Amp Hours/Day
Saloon CCF Double Light: 1.29 Amps x 6 Hours/Day = 7.74 Amp Hours/Day
Aft Stateroom Light: 20 Amps x 1 Hour/Day = 20 Amp Hours/Day
Aft Head Light: 20 Amps x 1 Hour/Day = 20 Amp Hours/Day
Fore Berth Swivel Light: 20 Amps x 0.25 Hours/Day = 5 Amp Hours/Day
Galley Fluorescent: 1.33 Amps x 10 Hours/Day = 13 Amp Hours/Day
Future Devices (Add Later):
Radar
Ham Radio
Autopilot
Total Daily Amp Hour Requirements:
Total Daily D/C Requirement without Future Devices = 293.12 Amp Hours
Miscellaneous A/C Device Requirements:
720 Amp Hours for Stove (Use of alcohol for stove or George Foreman grill will reduce this)
40 Amp Hours for 10 hours of TV (May not be used)
29 Amp Hours if using the DVD Recorder for 10 hours (Or same as 15 hours of TV without DVD)-May not apply
Microwave time has not been figured and will compete with grill time – Figuring 1 hour/day = 100 Amp Hours
Total = 889 Amp Hours/Day
Total = 293.12 Amp Hours (D/C) + 889 Amp Hours (A/C Total) = 1182.12 Amp Hours/Day
Battery Computations:
Charge from 50% - 85% (35% Battery Capacity) charges quickly; Slow charge from 85%-100%
Always keep a battery charged over 50%
35% of 245 Amp-Hour Battery = 85.75 Quick Charge Amps/Battery
50% of 245 Amp-Hour Battery = 122.5 Full 50% Amps/Battery
85.75 Quick Charge Amps x 12 Batteries = 1029 Amps/Day (Per Charging rather than Per Day)
122.5 Full 50% Amps/Battery x 12 Batteries = 1470 Amps/Day (Per Charging rather than Per Day)
10 Amps Charge x 24 Hours = 240 Amps/Day for each wind generator
293.12 Amp Hours/Day + 889 Amp Hours/Day = 1182.12 Amp Hours/Day
1182.12 Amp Hours/Day Divided By 85.75 Quick Charge Amps/Battery = 13.79 Batteries
1182.12 Amp Hours/Day Divided By 122.5 Total Amps/Battery = 9.65 Batteries
Need 12 Batteries under aft berth and 2 new batteries under Nav seat
1182.12 Amp Hours/Day Divided by 40 Charging Amps = 29.55 hours (Over a day)
1182.12 Amp Hours/Day Divided by 50 Charging Amps = 23.64 hours (Less than a day)
Note: More charge with solar panels will reduce the number of batteries needed since power can be used and restored during the day for many items. Additional items like radar must be factored, however, to come up with new totals.Leave a comment:
-
OK, I did some quick deletions and need to do a lot more editing on this, so it is not correct, but will give you some idea of the thought process, at least. I want to leave work for the day so I'm sending this as-is. Please don't beat me up too much because I really need to re-do all of this as it was preliminary, cursory work. I also have a minimum requirements list, but I'm not going to go through and delete stuff out of it now so here's a list of some equipment onboard and future additions on a wish list:
Power Requirements
A/C Power:
Origo Alcohol/Electrical Stove = 18.5 Amp Max for both burners; 120V A/C
2200 Watts at 120 VAC / 18.5 Amp Max. (1100 W per burner)
18.5 Amps x 120 Volts = 2220 Watts when running on A/C power
Skyworth 19” A/C-D/C TV ($549.99 from West Marine)
48 Watts (4 Amps at 12-Volts) – Verify this as info obtained online
George Foreman Grill = 1400 Watts
12.1739 (12.2) Amps x 115 Volts = 1400 Watts
D/C Power:
Norcold DE-490 Refrigerator:
- Data from West Marine = 0.4 Amps@110Volts -
A/C Draw: 0.4 Amps x 115 Volts = 46 Running Watts
D/C Draw: 3.1 Amps x 12 Volts = 37.2 Running Watts
- Data from Norcold = 0.83 Amps@120Volts -
A/C Draw: 0.83 Amps x 120 Volts = 99.6 Running Watts
D/C Draw: 3.1 Amps x 12 Volts = 37.2 Running Watts
Refrigerator to Panel requires 23 ft of wire (46 ft “round trip”). For 3% voltage drop=8AWG recommended
Currently using a 10-Amp fuse for D/C power to the refrigerator
Groco K-H 12-volt Head draws 12-18 Amps (Recommends a 25-Amp breaker) - Time use and times/day used
25 Amps x 12 Volts = 300 Watts Max; Averages 144 Watts – 216 Watts (12-18Amps)
Groco Head to Panel requires 23 ft – 25 ft of wire; Figure 50 ft “round trip” for 3% voltage drop=6 AWG recommended or for 10% drop=12 AWG recommended
Note: Can manually pump Groco head so this is not required.
Primary Bilge Pump; Jabsco Model 36600-0000; Recommends a 15-Amp breaker
11.0 Nominal Amps x 12 volts = 132 Watts
Bilge to Panel requires 18 ft of wire (36 ft “round trip”); For 3% voltage drop=8 AWG; For 10% voltage drop=16AWG; Used 14 AWG solid wire with red casing (approximately 7% voltage drop)
Replace Rule 3700 below with a non-submergible Jabsco pump instead like Primary Bilge Pump !!
Rule 3700 Secondary Bilge Pump = 15.5 Amps
There will be a tertiary bilge pump installed - No idea of model yet
Note: Replace 25 Watt bulbs with LED lights = 0.33 Amps x 12 Volts = 4 Watts
Bow Lights = (2) x 25 Watt bulbs --> 2.083 Amps x 12 Volts = 25 Watts for each bulb
Note: Bow Lights updated with LED bulbs so re-calculate power consumption
Stern Light = 10 Watt bulb --> 0.83 Amps x 12 Volts = 10 Watts -> Will replace with LED bulb !!
Masthead Light = 25 Watt bulb --> 2.083 Amps x 12 Volts = 25 Watts --> Will replace with LED bulb
Spreader Lights = ? Check Amps of Breaker// Replace with West Marine 55 Watt sealed beam lamps
Draws 4.6 Amps x 12 Volts = 55.2 Watts
Weems & Plath Commercial Grade Chartlite - $160
Draws 0.33 Amps x 12 Volts = 3.96 Watts (4 Watts)
Aft Stateroom Light by Clothes Locker = ? (10-20 Watts = 1-2 Amps)
Aft Head Light = ? (Probably 20 Watts = 2 Amps)
Water Pump = Paragon Workhorse; 14 Amps at mid-operating pressure range (16-30 PSI). Pumps from 18-34 PSI currently.
Coleman Iceless Cooler = 4 Amps (May not use on boat, we'll see-Buy real frig)
Fore, starboard 12-Volt Socket by Taylor heater = 15 Amp Breaker
Aft, starboard 12-Volt Socket in aft stateroom = 15 Amp Breaker
12-Volt D/C Outlet Plug under shower sole by Taylor heater = Run with 14 AWG solid, twisted pair wire
The following two devices recommend 16 AWG for the 12-Volt D/C Outlet Plug
Endless Breeze 12-Volt Fan:
Low: 1.18 Amps x 12 Volts = 14.16 Watts
Medium: 1.62 Amps x 12 Volts = 19.44 Watts
High: 2.58 Amps x 12 Volts = 30.96 Watts
Katadyn Watermaker 160e (6.7 GPH) = 18 Amps; 18 Amps x 12 Volts = 216 Watts
Starboard Lights
Total Amps for all Starboard Lights is 11.84-14.54 amps (134.84-164.84 Watts) depending on Hi/Lo selection
Now on a 10 Amp breaker
Note: For all “10 Watt” bulbs, call it 0.9 Amps x 12 Volts = 10.8 Watts (21.6 Watts on High)
Fore Clothes Locker – West Marine Interior Dome Light 5 ½” High/Off/Low Stainless
West Marine Model 151084 - $26.99; Has two 10-Watt bulbs (High uses both bulbs)
Replacement Bulb (Clear) = Model 460388; 0.8333 Amps x 12 Volts = 10 Watts on Low (20 Watts on High)
Fore Sink–Taylorbrite Cold Cathode Fluorescent (CCF) Single Brass Light; West Marine Model 3731734-$120
Dimmer Switch (Brass) Model 3731700 - $129; 0.63 Amps x 12 Volts = 7.56 Watts (Accurate Amps!)
Shower Shelf – West Marine Interior Dome Light 7” Clear/Red Stainless Model 540625 - $34.99
1 Red / 1 Clear 10 Watt G4 Xenon Bulb; 0.9 Amps x 12 Volts = 10.8 Watts for either bulb
Shower – West Marine 5” Exterior Dome Light – White, powder coat over chrome-plated zinc
West Marine Model 488478 - $39.99; 0.92 Amps x 12 Volts = 11 Watts (Bulb rated a generic “11 Watts”)
Saloon–Taylorbrite Cold Cathode Fluorescent (CCF) Double Brass Light; West Marine Model 3731759 - $180
Dimmer Switch (Brass) Model 3731700 - $129; 1.29 Amps x 12 Volts = 15.48 Watts (Accurate Amps !)
Fore Saloon Locker – West Marine Interior Dome Light 5 ½” High/Off/Low Brass (Titanium Nitride Finish)
West Marine Model 3292828 - $39.99 with two 10-Watt bulbs (High uses both bulbs); 10 Watt G4 Xenon bulb
Replacement Bulb (Clear) = Model 460388; 0.9 Amps x 12 Volts = 10.8 Watts on Low (21.6 Watts on High)
Fore Brass Swivel Light – Existing brass light believed to have a 20-Watt Xenon bulb
Aft Brass Swivel Light – Existing brass light believed to have a 20-Watt Xenon bulb
Aft Saloon Locker - Marine Interior Dome Light 5 ½” High/Off/Low Stainless
West Marine Model 151084 - $26.99; Has two 10-Watt bulbs (High uses both bulbs)
Replacement Bulb (Clear) = Model 460388; 0.9 Amps x 12 Volts = 10.8 Watts on Low (21.6 Watts on High)
Quarter Berth Brass Swivel Light – Existing brass light believed to have a 20-Watt Xenon bulb
Aft Stateroom Light – 20 Amp bulb x 12 Volts = 240 Watts
Port Lights
Total Amps for all Port Lights is 8.53 amps (106 Watts Max / 102.36 calculated Watts from 8.53 amps)
Note: For all “10 Watt” bulbs, call it 0.9 Amps x 12 Volts = 10.8 Watts (21.6 Watts on High)
Fore Double Swivel Light – Probably a 10-Watt bulb (35 ft of wire)-12 AWG for 10% drop
Fore Port Locker Light – 7” Stainless Steel Xenon Nav Dome Light; West Marine Model 540625
1 Red 10-Watt G-4 Xenon Bulb, 1 Clear 10-Watt G-4 Xenon Bulb (35 ft of wire)-12 AWG for 10% drop
Fore Berth Swivel Light – Existing brass light believed to have a 20-Watt Xenon Bulb (27 ft of wire)-10 AWG for 10% voltage drop
Galley Fluorescent – 2 Bulbs (Red/White) & 19 ft of wire; Rocker only allows 1 bulb on at a time (Each bulb is 15Watts, but a single bulb on website is shown as 16 Watt draw; 1.33 Amps x 12 Volts = 16 Watts
Galley Teak Swivel Lights (Two) – (22 ft of wire for one // 21 ft of wire for the other)-10 Amp bulb in each
For a 10% voltage drop=14 AWG wire recommended
Aft Head Light – Existing plastic light believed to have a 20-Amp bulb (35 ft of wire)-For 10% drop=8 AWG
Equipment Purchasing:
West Marine 8D Battery is made by East Penn Manufacturing in Pennsylvania
8D AGM = 245 Amp-Hours; Cost = $510; L=20.75” x W=11” x H=10”; 158lbs
20 Batteries = 4900Ah; ½ of this is 2450Ah; 30% of 4900Ah = 1470Ah
MasterVolt reviews show much better than Seavolt ... Update battery data from West Marine website
Page 397 of new catalog (http://ecatalog.westmarine.com/full.asp?page=397)
ME Series Modified Sine Wave Inverters/Chargers
ME3112-U = 3100Watts continuous/6000Watts Surge/160Amp Charger Output - $1489 + Accessories
ME-RC Remote Control = $187.99; Battery Monitor Kit = $142.99
-Or- Page 390; Link 2000 Inverter/Charge Control & Two-Bank Battery Monitor = $354.99
Daily A/C Equipment Amp Hour Requirements:
A/C Watt Hours divided by 10 approximates Amp-Hours for battery
For example, (1000 Watt microwave x 1 hour) / 10 = 100 Amp Hours
Cooking & Entertainment:
Electric Stove = 2400 Watts x 3 hour/day = 7200 / 10 --> 720 Amp Hours/Day
TV = 40 Watts x 10 hours/day = 400 / 10 --> 40 Amp Hours/Day
DVD Recorder = 29 Watts x 10 hours/day = 290 / 10 --> 29 Amp Hours/Day
George Foreman Grill = 1400 Watts 12.1739 (12.2) Amps x 115 Volts = 1400 Watts
(1400 Watts x 1 Hour)/10 = 140 Amp Hours (vs. 240 Amp Hours for 1 Hour of Electric Stove)
Note: DVD Recorder was deleted from mix, but there will be laptops to add back so leaving as-is until I can update this
Total Daily Amp Hour Requirements:
720 Amp Hours for Stove (Use of alcohol for stove or George Foreman grill will reduce this)
40 Amp Hours for 10 hours of TV
29 Amp Hours if using the DVD Recorder for 10 hours (Or same as 15 hours of TV without DVD)
Microwave time has not been figured and will compete with grill time – Figuring 1 hour/day = 100 Amp Hours
Total: 889 Amp Hours/Day
Got to break this up as it's too long ...Leave a comment:
-
Without knowing this you can't just throw batteries in the boat based on a guess.Leave a comment:
-
Concorde makes a 2V 1100AH battery and smaller too if you want to have 2 house banks.Leave a comment:
-
You are going to have TWO banks of batteries. And a starting battery for your diesel. And I would scrap the 12V batteries and go with 6V.Leave a comment:
-
The sailplan with the B&R carries a huge main with a big roach that develops unbelievable power. All the genoa does on a B&R is provide a little balance. The drive and power is in the main. So boats with a B&R can point really high with a small jib and on a reach you'd better hang on because you're going for a ride. On a run they're not so great because of the angle you can swing the boom being limited by the rig. They're still VERY fast on a run. But an accidental gybe is always a possibility so experienced sailors rig a preventer on them. You swing a 16 foot boom stop to stop under full sail and you'll break either the mainsheet or the traveler car.
Overall, I like the B&R. It's like driving a ho-hum Camaro with a 2Bbl 350 vs the same car with a ZL-1 427 big block.
Back to your battery problem, what exactly are the daily loads on your boat? The first thing you buy, before you spend money on anything else, is a Bogart Engineering Pentametric Battery Monitor. The Pentametric is designed for multiple shunts so it can track more than one battery bank. It is almost the defacto-standard battery meter used on sailing yachts.Leave a comment:
-
To bring things back on track, so far I have feedback to run two Kyocera 300 watt solar panels hooked in serial to a 60 amp MPPT controller (I'm thinking the MPPT controller should be mounted near a battery bank to which it will connect).
6-8 MasterVolt Super 8D AGM Batteries (12-volt 270AH) broken down into how many banks --> 3-4 banks of 2 batteries each for greatest flexibility ??
So I'm hooking 2 panels per MPPT controller into a bank of 2 batteries ?? Sound right?
What happens when I connect multiple banks of batteries to the main panel? They will all be interconnected at the panel through ... a switch or secondary panel ?? ... How should this be handled and will I get to toast marshmallows when I flip the switch(es)?Thoughts ??
Leave a comment:
-
The Columbia 50 was actually designed as a race boat by naval architect Bill Tripp. They still race 'em ... They do about 7-8 knots, but definitely more of a cruising vessel. They are very responsive boats and naturally track well with a 7ft keel.
B&R Rig - No backstay !! It must be tough to tension the jib in high winds, I would think. Nice sloped back design. Not a fan of in-mast roller furling either and also stay away from the "push button" stuff ... Keep it simple
I bought my Columbia 50 from its original owner, who had another 1/16" of fiberglass added to the hull at the Costa Mesa site as well as had them properly align the chainplate and double-core the deck. I looked around the world for the right one and found mine in Costa del Rey.Leave a comment:
Copyright © 2014 SolarReviews All rights reserved.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 6.1.0
Copyright © 2025 MH Sub I, LLC dba vBulletin. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 2025 MH Sub I, LLC dba vBulletin. All rights reserved.
All times are GMT-5. This page was generated at 12:41 AM.
Leave a comment: