Question about FLA battery charging.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • AzRoute66
    replied
    Originally posted by sensij
    Oh my. What a steaming mess. Is that actually from Sandia or is that some kind of farce paper like a MIT version of The Onion? Looks like two high school kids got a hold of a new piece of test equipment and had to kill a few weeks before the next project picked up steam.

    Come on. Tell the truth. What is the origin of this drivel?

    Leave a comment:


  • sensij
    replied
    Originally posted by AzRoute66
    Sunkings posts #3 and #8 answered a question for me that I didn't even know that I had - but I had a gut feeling I should.
    You might enjoy this paper:

    https://www.solarpaneltalk.com/filed...2&d=1336278119





    Leave a comment:


  • AzRoute66
    replied
    Sunkings posts #3 and #8 answered a question for me that I didn't even know that I had - but I had a gut feeling I should. Since I had to dredge all the way back to Page 17 of the Batteries Forum (May 2015) to find it I thought it might be worded in such a way that it will also help others. (I'm sure the concept has been re-articulated since then but it wasn't in such a way that I appreciated it fully at the time). So, here is a bump up for a thread that hopefully helps others as it did for me.

    Thanks Sunking

    Leave a comment:


  • Sunking
    replied
    Originally posted by paulcheung
    It is a pity, I love Rolls battery. they got a lot business in Jamaica, most of the people I know or talk to use Rolls battery. If Trojan prove smart carbon works then they will take some business from them if Rolls just sit there, I know my next bank will be Trojan.
    Price, Warranty, and Brand Recognition will keep its loyal customers Top of the line Rolls 5000 series carries a 10 year warranty for around $240/Kwh. Trojan 8 year IND line-up is around $300/Kwh. Both have Brand Recognition and well respected with over 60 years experience. You can most certainly bet Rolls is working on their version. Trojan is just a leader, Rolls is still trying to catch up.

    Remember every battery manufacture out there and some never heard of are in a race to bring a super battery to market. Has been for the last 15 years. Like everything there are no Quantum Leaps, just incremental improvements. Remember the first consumer computers? There was no Quantum leap to what we have today. 20 years from now our Grand Children will laugh at your antiquated Apple, Android gizmos we have today.

    Leave a comment:


  • paulcheung
    replied
    Originally posted by Sunking
    Only thing Rolls has done is raise Set Point Voltages as Trojan has done. They have done away with 3-Stage setting and moved to CC/CV set to 2.5 vpc. Note for RE systems only, not standard battery chargers.
    It is a pity, I love Rolls battery. they got a lot business in Jamaica, most of the people I know or talk to use Rolls battery. If Trojan prove smart carbon works then they will take some business from them if Rolls just sit there, I know my next bank will be Trojan.

    Thanks.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sunking
    replied
    Originally posted by paulcheung
    Dereck what is Rolls doing now? do they have any thing to deal with this PSOC problem? Are they just sit there?
    Only thing Rolls has done is raise Set Point Voltages as Trojan has done. They have done away with 3-Stage setting and moved to CC/CV set to 2.5 vpc. Note for RE systems only, not standard battery chargers.

    Leave a comment:


  • paulcheung
    replied
    Originally posted by Sunking
    Yes which is what PSOC application is. Trojan is not saying to operate 20-80% range.
    Yes, I know they didn't say operate 20-80% range, but if PSOC is not a problem, then operate at 20-80% will make battery much cooler and just saturate the battery once a week or so. the battery should be last much longer. right now my battery at the afternoon the temperature is over 110 degree F.

    Dereck what is Rolls doing now? do they have any thing to deal with this PSOC problem? Are they just sit there?

    Leave a comment:


  • Sunking
    replied
    Originally posted by paulcheung
    Isn't the sulfation the biggest problem on FLA battery for PV application?
    Yes which is what PSOC application is. Trojan is not saying to operate 20-80% range.

    Leave a comment:


  • paulcheung
    replied
    If Trojan premium and Industrial line is truly PSOC, then it will work like the lithium as long as you stay in the 20 to 80% DOD range and within the C/20 to C/30 discharge and C/8 to C/12 charge rate. Isn't the sulfation the biggest problem on FLA battery for PV application?

    Leave a comment:


  • Willy T
    replied
    Originally posted by Sunking
    That would be a job for lithium.
    Thats why I have a $2,500 test bank. Before I quadruple it, I want to know what I am getting into.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sunking
    replied
    Originally posted by Willy T
    I agree with you, that sweet spot is usually expressed somewhere between 50 - 60 %. The other charging scheme is to charge to 85 % daily and absorb once a week to 10 days to 100%. I haven't figured it out in 30 years of being part time off grid. The weather usually dictates what I do. Running the Generator once week sometimes works out just for fuel costs alone.
    That would be a job for lithium.

    Leave a comment:


  • SunEagle
    replied
    Originally posted by Willy T
    I agree with you, that sweet spot is usually expressed somewhere between 50 - 60 %. The other charging scheme is to charge to 85 % daily and absorb once a week to 10 days to 100%. I haven't figured it out in 30 years of being part time off grid. The weather usually dictates what I do. Running the Generator once week sometimes works out just for fuel costs alone.
    There you go again blaming the weather on less solar capture.

    My guess as battery technology improves then hopefully that sweet spot increases.

    Leave a comment:


  • Willy T
    replied
    Originally posted by SunEagle
    Ok. With an 80% DOD you can get more kwh output "per cycle" but have to replace the batteries in 1/4 the time then only going using a 20% DOD. That math works on the table but will it work in real life?

    My fear is that going below 50% DOD puts more strain on the battery that could result with less then the listed cycle count.

    Just about all types of electrical devices have efficiency curves that are not linear. The same goes for their lifespan based on usage. Harder usage usually means much shorter life where that "curve" is not a straight line.

    Maybe there is a happy medium between 20 and 80% that gets you the best bang for your buck.
    I agree with you, that sweet spot is usually expressed somewhere between 50 - 60 %. The other charging scheme is to charge to 85 % daily and absorb once a week to 10 days to 100%. I haven't figured it out in 30 years of being part time off grid. The weather usually dictates what I do. Running the Generator once week sometimes works out just for fuel costs alone.

    Leave a comment:


  • SunEagle
    replied
    Originally posted by paulcheung
    If you discharge the battery to 20% DOD and discharge to 80% DOD and get the same amount of watts in the battery life. For example the L16RE-B has 4000 cycle at 20% DOD and has 1000 cycle at 80% DOD, you get the same amount KWH for it's life no matter how deep you discharge as long you stay in 20 to 80%.
    Ok. With an 80% DOD you can get more kwh output "per cycle" but have to replace the batteries in 1/4 the time then only going using a 20% DOD. That math works on the table but will it work in real life?

    My fear is that going below 50% DOD puts more strain on the battery that could result with less then the listed cycle count.

    Just about all types of electrical devices have efficiency curves that are not linear. The same goes for their lifespan based on usage. Harder usage usually means much shorter life where that "curve" is not a straight line.

    Maybe there is a happy medium between 20 and 80% that gets you the best bang for your buck.

    Leave a comment:


  • paulcheung
    replied
    Originally posted by Sunking
    Not sure what you are saying Paul.
    If you discharge the battery to 20% DOD and discharge to 80% DOD and get the same amount of watts in the battery life. For example the L16RE-B has 4000 cycle at 20% DOD and has 1000 cycle at 80% DOD, you get the same amount KWH for it's life no matter how deep you discharge as long you stay in 20 to 80%.

    Leave a comment:

Working...